The book Hate That Cat by Sharon Creech is the well-written and heartwarming follow-up story to Love That Dog, both of which are novels in verse. The books follow a young boy as he learns to appreciate poetry for what it can be rather than what it always “must” be. In this second book, Ms. Stretchberry is able to bring more sophisticated poetry mechanics to life for her students. By reading the thoughts of Jack—in poem form—as he learns about alliteration and onomatopoeia while overcoming the loss of his dog Sky, Creech creates a story that is both heartfelt and educational. Her use of poetry and first person diary-esque dialogue invites readers into Jack’s world and lets readers learn to about poetry themselves, first hand.
Creech’s ability to show readers what is going on inside of Jacks mind is a key aspect of the novel. As the reader follows Jack they learn more and more about his feelings and relationships with the things around him. The one-sided aspect of the journal should, perhaps, make it difficult to keep up with the dialogue between Jack and Ms. Stretchberry but Creech counters this by giving the journal a sense of continued dialogue. It is easy enough to determine what is going on both within the journal and in the outside world simply by connecting the journal entries to one another.
After reading Love That Dog, it seems as though there is nothing more the reader can learn about Jack, but during the reading of his second poetry journal more details about him are brought to life in a way that enhances his charm and highlights the effects of poetry on all manners of people. Creech emphasizes some of the key pieces of figurative language that are often associated with poetry in the text, alliteration and onomatopoeia. While she uses many different examples in Jack’s entries to illustrate the meaning and use of these devices, she is sure to point out that they are not essential parts of the poem. Creech creates a foil to Jack’s poems and beliefs about poetry in the form of Jack’s Uncle Bill—a university professor. Uncle Bill is highly critical not only of Jack’s poems but also the poems of William Carlos Williams and other famous authors discussed in Ms. Stretchberry’s class.
The most remarkable aspect of the text is Creech’s development of Jack’s understanding of poetry. In the text, Jack poses a very good question, “if you cannot hear/ do words have no sounds/ in your head?/ Do you see/ a/ silent/ movie?” (16). He poses a similar question about the use of onomatopoeia and how sound words would be interpreted by someone who cannot hear. These questions lead the reader to wonder why they appear in Jack’s journal. We learn that Jack’s mother is deaf and that she feels sound—tapping out the rhythm. Jack’s mother serves not only as a catalyst for these questions about poetry and sound, but also as a reminder readers that the emotions, thoughts, images, etc. evoked by a poem are more important than a poem’s form, rhythm, and style. It is these qualities that make poems worth the reader’s time—something Jack comes to understand despite his Uncle Bill’s protestations.
Creech uses Jack and his family as the protagonists in the fight against those who dread and fear poetry. By using a child’s reactions and opinions to poetry—especially “classic” poetry from authors like Tennyson and Poe—Creech empowers readers; she gives them the tools and ability to look at poetry with a fresh and confidant eye. No longer is poetry the dreaded, impossible compilation of words on a page, it is the ticking of a clock, the purring of a cat, the image of an eagle clasping a rock with its talons. Creech entertains, empowers, and teaches her audience to appreciate and confidently approach poetry by showing readers the path of understanding taken by Jack as ha navigates through the misconceptions of poetry. The novel is a clever, disguised learning experience that is enjoyable for all who encounter it.
Monday, November 16, 2009
Saturday, November 14, 2009
CI 5442: Non-Fiction Response #1
I was excited to start reading Jennifer Armstrong’s Shipwreck at the Bottom of the World. Flipping through the text I was drawn to the images of the men and the clear struggles they faced based on the documentation provided by the photographs. Non-fiction can be a difficult genre to really engage with unless you are particularly interested in the topic or there is a human component to the presentation of the material that draws you in. This text is able to combine these two elements and create a narrative that is captivating for anyone despite their interests.
The first few pages provided nothing more than basic information about the journey and the area in which the Endurance was about to traverse. At first I was worried that I wouldn’t get the story I wanted most—about the men themselves—but, Armstrong was not about to disappoint me. Soon, I was learning about the crew and imagining their antics: from practical jokes to skiing attempts. I was also sitting on the edge of my seat as I read about the tight time-frame the men had to deal with, “If Shackleton did not reach the edge of the continent before the end of the short Antarctic summer, the ice would shut him out” (15). I tried to imagine the agony of being forced to wait at the whaling station before traveling on in hopes of being the first to travel across Antarctica; a lofty goal with so many obstacles and odds set against them.
As I continued to read I was drawn by the humanity of the men aboard the Endurance. Because of the remarkably thorough documentation and reports of the entire crew, not only did I feel as though I was getting to know some of the men, but I also felt tied to their journey. The book takes the reader through the hard times as well as the uplifting or light-hearted moments experienced by the crew in a way that invests the reader in both the lives of the men and their expedition. We are able to see the men as they were beyond their occupations—they were young men setting out for adventure; men who played pranks, held races, and made toasts such as, “ To our sweethearts and wives—may they never meet” (20).
Shackleton himself stood out to me among the members of the crew. While I was nervous to read at the beginning of the book that he didn’t make emergency plans and was a seat-of-his-pants kind of guy, he turned out to be the driving force behind the successful rescue of his men. It is obvious when reading the comments of the crew and Shackleton’s own account that he always held the good of his men as his top priority. He worked hard to ensure that spirits and morale was maintained as much as possible—breaking up disagreements and never letting the crew know if a break was meant specifically for them as they travelled across the barren ice and sea of the Antarctic. When they must leave the ship, Shackleton leaves behind gold coins but orders Hussey to take his banjo, “because they would need the comfort of music in the hard times ahead” (52). When the crew’s temporary ice camp cracked he alerted them and helped them to get across to the “safe” side of the floe as he stayed “behind to ensure that all of his men got over safely” (80).
After leaving most of the crew of Elephant Island in order to go seek aid, Shackleton continues to think about the needs of his men. South Georgia Island, across 800 miles of open sea in a small dingy not meant for such trying use, the men left behind pushed the Shackleton and the others to the brink. Armstrong notes, “He was tormented with the thought of the twenty-two men waiting for him. They were waiting for him. The Boss. For months they had placed all their hopes and lives in his hands” (107). Thus he decides to trek across the “Alps of the Southern Ocean” a feat never accomplished before. His duty to his men pushed him, “He could not rest now, when only when only twenty-nine miles separated him from rescue for his men” (107). When he is finally able to reunite with his men, Shackleton is paid the highest of compliments, “We knew you’d come back” (123). Shackleton exemplifies the qualities desired in a leader among men and this account serves as a testament of his duty to ensure the survival of his men.
Armstrong is able to combine the personal accounts of the journey with detailed information about the dangers and scientific aspects of the traveling through the Antarctic Circle during the early twentieth century in a way that is informative and interesting at the same time. She threads the information within the story of the men and their survival flawlessly. Even though I am not particularly interested in sea-travel at the turn of the twentieth century I was drawn into the details of the trip by their connection to the journey of the Endurance. Armstrong is able to present the information using highly literary and engaging language that allows the setting to become a character in the plot and the scientific aspects of the journey and setting to become integral pieces in developing the plot. She claims that the timbers of the ship “began to complain” under the pressure from the ice, or describing the riptide “roaring after them, threatening to engulf the three puny boats with a deluge of ice and slush,” effectively characterizing the men’s surroundings in an almost lyrical narrative style (39, 79).
Armstrong’s retelling of this amazing feat of human endurance is entertaining and informative in equal amounts. I learned a lot but never felt overwhelmed by the information presented in the text. She smoothly transitions information from primary accounts of those among the Endurance with the history and dangers associated with the area and travel during the beginning of the twentieth century. The photographs add to the validity of the accounts within the text and draw the reader into the lives of the men as they battle against nature and time. In the end Armstrong is able to create a piece of non-fiction that draws the reader in so much that they become absorbed in the details and fate of the Endurance and her brave crew.
The first few pages provided nothing more than basic information about the journey and the area in which the Endurance was about to traverse. At first I was worried that I wouldn’t get the story I wanted most—about the men themselves—but, Armstrong was not about to disappoint me. Soon, I was learning about the crew and imagining their antics: from practical jokes to skiing attempts. I was also sitting on the edge of my seat as I read about the tight time-frame the men had to deal with, “If Shackleton did not reach the edge of the continent before the end of the short Antarctic summer, the ice would shut him out” (15). I tried to imagine the agony of being forced to wait at the whaling station before traveling on in hopes of being the first to travel across Antarctica; a lofty goal with so many obstacles and odds set against them.
As I continued to read I was drawn by the humanity of the men aboard the Endurance. Because of the remarkably thorough documentation and reports of the entire crew, not only did I feel as though I was getting to know some of the men, but I also felt tied to their journey. The book takes the reader through the hard times as well as the uplifting or light-hearted moments experienced by the crew in a way that invests the reader in both the lives of the men and their expedition. We are able to see the men as they were beyond their occupations—they were young men setting out for adventure; men who played pranks, held races, and made toasts such as, “ To our sweethearts and wives—may they never meet” (20).
Shackleton himself stood out to me among the members of the crew. While I was nervous to read at the beginning of the book that he didn’t make emergency plans and was a seat-of-his-pants kind of guy, he turned out to be the driving force behind the successful rescue of his men. It is obvious when reading the comments of the crew and Shackleton’s own account that he always held the good of his men as his top priority. He worked hard to ensure that spirits and morale was maintained as much as possible—breaking up disagreements and never letting the crew know if a break was meant specifically for them as they travelled across the barren ice and sea of the Antarctic. When they must leave the ship, Shackleton leaves behind gold coins but orders Hussey to take his banjo, “because they would need the comfort of music in the hard times ahead” (52). When the crew’s temporary ice camp cracked he alerted them and helped them to get across to the “safe” side of the floe as he stayed “behind to ensure that all of his men got over safely” (80).
After leaving most of the crew of Elephant Island in order to go seek aid, Shackleton continues to think about the needs of his men. South Georgia Island, across 800 miles of open sea in a small dingy not meant for such trying use, the men left behind pushed the Shackleton and the others to the brink. Armstrong notes, “He was tormented with the thought of the twenty-two men waiting for him. They were waiting for him. The Boss. For months they had placed all their hopes and lives in his hands” (107). Thus he decides to trek across the “Alps of the Southern Ocean” a feat never accomplished before. His duty to his men pushed him, “He could not rest now, when only when only twenty-nine miles separated him from rescue for his men” (107). When he is finally able to reunite with his men, Shackleton is paid the highest of compliments, “We knew you’d come back” (123). Shackleton exemplifies the qualities desired in a leader among men and this account serves as a testament of his duty to ensure the survival of his men.
Armstrong is able to combine the personal accounts of the journey with detailed information about the dangers and scientific aspects of the traveling through the Antarctic Circle during the early twentieth century in a way that is informative and interesting at the same time. She threads the information within the story of the men and their survival flawlessly. Even though I am not particularly interested in sea-travel at the turn of the twentieth century I was drawn into the details of the trip by their connection to the journey of the Endurance. Armstrong is able to present the information using highly literary and engaging language that allows the setting to become a character in the plot and the scientific aspects of the journey and setting to become integral pieces in developing the plot. She claims that the timbers of the ship “began to complain” under the pressure from the ice, or describing the riptide “roaring after them, threatening to engulf the three puny boats with a deluge of ice and slush,” effectively characterizing the men’s surroundings in an almost lyrical narrative style (39, 79).
Armstrong’s retelling of this amazing feat of human endurance is entertaining and informative in equal amounts. I learned a lot but never felt overwhelmed by the information presented in the text. She smoothly transitions information from primary accounts of those among the Endurance with the history and dangers associated with the area and travel during the beginning of the twentieth century. The photographs add to the validity of the accounts within the text and draw the reader into the lives of the men as they battle against nature and time. In the end Armstrong is able to create a piece of non-fiction that draws the reader in so much that they become absorbed in the details and fate of the Endurance and her brave crew.
Sunday, November 8, 2009
CI 5442: Science Fiction Response #2
Alright, The Giver. I read this book in fifth grade and I hated it. I admit that part of this might have been caused by my mother who expressed her distaste for the book to me when she found out that I was reading it. Because of this and the fact that everyone just loves I thought I would read it again. Reading it now I can see why people like it, but it still makes me uncomfortable. I think Jonas is a great character and I was relieved when both he and the Giver decide to force emotions back into the community but their society bothers me so much. I think my discomfort with science fiction is my apprehension that dystopian societies could be created or that they are on their way to being built already.
Jonas is the one redeeming character in the book for me—the Giver to a lesser extent. Jonas thinks carefully about his words throughout the text illustrating a connection with language that others don’t seem to possess. Even when he is receiving memories from the Giver he is attuned to his lack of language. He grasps the power of words such as warmth, family, grandparents, and love as well as more negative and painful words like war, pain, and death. For the amount of emphasis his community places on the precision of language, it is remarkable how much they miss with the lack of memories and real feelings. Jonas asks his parents his parents if they love him and their response illustrates the lack of depth within their emotions and actions within the community. His father replies, “You of all people. Precision of language, please!” while his mother explains:
Your father means that you used a very generalized word, so meaningless that it’s become almost obsolete….our community can’t function smoothly if people don’t use precise language. You could ask, ‘Do you enjoy me?’ The answer is ‘Yes’….Do you understand why it’s inappropriate to use a word like ‘love’? (127)
It’s sad to think that a word as powerful as love could be reduced to mere “enjoyment” and “pride” the way Jonas’ parents describe their affection for him and his sister. I think that Lowry is able to provide readers with a glimpse into a bleak existence without emotions by emphasizing the power of language through Jonas.
Clearly language is tied to emotion, but as Jonas learns, both emotion and language are firmly grounded in memory. A powerful moment for me in the text was when Jonas attempts to rejoin his childhood friends in a game of “good guy” versus “bad guy.” A game he had played many times, yet, “He never recognized it before as a game of war” (133). He pleads with his friends to stop the game saying, “You had no way of knowing this. I didn’t know it myself until recently. But it’s a cruel game” (134). His friends don’t have the same memories as Jonas and therefore they don’t understand. It’s like when you are a kid and you hear a bad word for the first time and then you go around using it because you don’t know what it means and why it is inappropriate.
My least favorite part in the book is when Jonas sees his father “releasing” a newly born infant because it is the smaller of two identical twins. I was as horrified as Jonas to “see” the needle being driven into the smaller infants head until his struggles ceased. For Jonas’ father, it isn’t a big deal and he dumps the baby into something resembling “the same sort of chute into which trash was deposited at school” (150). That is exactly the image that killed this book for me when I was younger and even reading it again it gives me chills. I think Lowry wanted to illustrate the disconnect achieved by the members in society because of their lack of memories and feelings—attributes that define our species and set us apart from other creatures. Without these elements humans become nothing more than empty shells.
I was so relieved when Jonas inspires the Giver to understand the importance of memories and the need to release them back into the community. Although the pair knows that releasing the memories will be difficult and painful for the community, but in the end the memories will release the community from their meaningless and empty existence. The Giver notes that memories “are forever” and need to be shared (144). He notes that the people will be in great need of him once the memories are returned to them and, therefore, he won’t be able to leave with Jonas. He tells Jonas, “The worst part of holding the memories is not the pain. It’s the loneliness of it. Memories need to be shared” (154). Only through expression and communication can we—as humans—come to terms with experiences, emotions, and events in our lives.
Lowry creates a world that enables readers to see the importance and significance of the entire spectrum of human experiences—from unbelievable suffering and pain to blissful moments of happiness and love. Readers can explore the power of language and memories by entering a dystopian society. The novel explores extreme control in a safe and hypothetical environment—but that doesn’t make it any less disturbing. While the premise of the story still bothers me I will acknowledge that it did make me think about the world and the future; especially in terms of what I can do to prevent such an existence from becoming a reality.
Jonas is the one redeeming character in the book for me—the Giver to a lesser extent. Jonas thinks carefully about his words throughout the text illustrating a connection with language that others don’t seem to possess. Even when he is receiving memories from the Giver he is attuned to his lack of language. He grasps the power of words such as warmth, family, grandparents, and love as well as more negative and painful words like war, pain, and death. For the amount of emphasis his community places on the precision of language, it is remarkable how much they miss with the lack of memories and real feelings. Jonas asks his parents his parents if they love him and their response illustrates the lack of depth within their emotions and actions within the community. His father replies, “You of all people. Precision of language, please!” while his mother explains:
Your father means that you used a very generalized word, so meaningless that it’s become almost obsolete….our community can’t function smoothly if people don’t use precise language. You could ask, ‘Do you enjoy me?’ The answer is ‘Yes’….Do you understand why it’s inappropriate to use a word like ‘love’? (127)
It’s sad to think that a word as powerful as love could be reduced to mere “enjoyment” and “pride” the way Jonas’ parents describe their affection for him and his sister. I think that Lowry is able to provide readers with a glimpse into a bleak existence without emotions by emphasizing the power of language through Jonas.
Clearly language is tied to emotion, but as Jonas learns, both emotion and language are firmly grounded in memory. A powerful moment for me in the text was when Jonas attempts to rejoin his childhood friends in a game of “good guy” versus “bad guy.” A game he had played many times, yet, “He never recognized it before as a game of war” (133). He pleads with his friends to stop the game saying, “You had no way of knowing this. I didn’t know it myself until recently. But it’s a cruel game” (134). His friends don’t have the same memories as Jonas and therefore they don’t understand. It’s like when you are a kid and you hear a bad word for the first time and then you go around using it because you don’t know what it means and why it is inappropriate.
My least favorite part in the book is when Jonas sees his father “releasing” a newly born infant because it is the smaller of two identical twins. I was as horrified as Jonas to “see” the needle being driven into the smaller infants head until his struggles ceased. For Jonas’ father, it isn’t a big deal and he dumps the baby into something resembling “the same sort of chute into which trash was deposited at school” (150). That is exactly the image that killed this book for me when I was younger and even reading it again it gives me chills. I think Lowry wanted to illustrate the disconnect achieved by the members in society because of their lack of memories and feelings—attributes that define our species and set us apart from other creatures. Without these elements humans become nothing more than empty shells.
I was so relieved when Jonas inspires the Giver to understand the importance of memories and the need to release them back into the community. Although the pair knows that releasing the memories will be difficult and painful for the community, but in the end the memories will release the community from their meaningless and empty existence. The Giver notes that memories “are forever” and need to be shared (144). He notes that the people will be in great need of him once the memories are returned to them and, therefore, he won’t be able to leave with Jonas. He tells Jonas, “The worst part of holding the memories is not the pain. It’s the loneliness of it. Memories need to be shared” (154). Only through expression and communication can we—as humans—come to terms with experiences, emotions, and events in our lives.
Lowry creates a world that enables readers to see the importance and significance of the entire spectrum of human experiences—from unbelievable suffering and pain to blissful moments of happiness and love. Readers can explore the power of language and memories by entering a dystopian society. The novel explores extreme control in a safe and hypothetical environment—but that doesn’t make it any less disturbing. While the premise of the story still bothers me I will acknowledge that it did make me think about the world and the future; especially in terms of what I can do to prevent such an existence from becoming a reality.
CI 5442: Science Fiction Response #1
I was a bit apprehensive about diving into science fiction, especially a novel about clones, but I found Nancy Farmer’s The House of the Scorpion to be a disturbing yet completely engrossing text. I found myself caring about Matt and the decisions he made throughout the text. I cringed when he forced his Maria to kiss him at El Patron’s birthday party and I sympathized with his bought of severe acne after working at the shrimp harvesting company. Nevertheless, I still shudder at some of the topics within the novel and ideas that are in science fiction.
The most interesting piece of Farmer’s story was the stigma attached to being a clone. From the moment Matt’s foot is read by those in the Alacran house he is ostracized and viewed as nothing more than an animal. Rosa, the unfortunate housekeeper who is forced to care for Matt, literally treats him as an animal by providing him with newspapers as a lavatory. She eventually puts down chicken litter to make it easier for her to care for him. Willum, the doctor, remarks about Rosa’s decision saying, “You’re a strange woman, Rosa, but I have to admit the beast’s in good condition” (43). Even Maria, Matt’s only friend, continues to consider Matt to be an animal by comparing him to her dog, Furball. Eventually even Matt begins to believe that he is an animal. He tells Maria, “ ‘I am an animal,’ he replied. Once those words would have pained him, but he accepted his status now” (92). The only people who don’t treat him like an animal are Celia and Tam Lin. Both adults treat Matt like a human and expect more from him.
During El Patron’s 143rd birthday party, after Matt behaves like an animal in a figurative way. After the treatment of Tom, the embarrassing gift and kiss situation with Maria, the mysterious death of Furball, Matt’s anger turns to heartache as he realizes how his behavior can eventually poison his behavior and his future. Yet he remembers the words of Tam Lin, “Any rat in a sewer can lie….But a human doesn’t run and hide in dark places, because he’s something more” (134). At first this does nothing but drive Matt further into his own torment, but then he realizes that such a statement mirrors Tam Lin’s treatment of him as different from others. “He treated Matt as an equal” (138). In this Matt finds hope from, “Someone, out of all the people who thought he was no better than a dog, believed he could be something more” (139). It is from that moment on that Matt really decides to be a better person than Matteo Alacran, the original.
Matt and El Patron have a very strange relationship throughout the novel. I myself was very curious as to what the purpose for Matt’s creation and El Patron’s reason for not wanting to have a chip inserted into his brain. It was well into the novel that I began to doubt the sincerity and benevolence behind El Patron’s decisions. Every moment from then on in which there was any kind of foreshadow to perpetuate these thoughts, I physically cringed. It was heartbreaking for me and I tried to deny it as much as possible, just as Matt did, but when the awful truth came out I was terrified for Matt. It was only through my faith and trust in Celia, Tam Lin, and Maria to get him out safely that I was able to continue reading the book. When I get really involved in a novel it is hard for me to continue reading if I feel any apprehension for the well-being of the characters.
My favorite part in the book was when Tam Lin lets Matt know the secret about clones. He whispers into Matt’s ear, “No one can tell the difference between a clone and a human. That’s because there isn’t any difference. The idea of clones being inferior is a filthy lie” (245). This is something that helps Matt when he finally escapes Opium and enters Aztlan—escaping one dystopia for another. In Atzlan, Matt isn’t looked down upon for being a clone, instead he is singled out for being “the aristocrat” (280). With the Lost Boys and the Keepers Matt faces a new world filled with misplaced and hypocritical Socialists. The Keepers are unable to really practice what they preach and essentially imprison the boys while they spend the days eating and taking drugs. In this new land Matt gains his first male friends his own age who don’t treat him differently for being a clone—even after their initial misgivings. Matt is quick to point out to the Keepers that they are attempting to turn the boys into zombies or the eejits created in Opium.
I was relieved in the end when the all the boys finally see through their disillusionment and take things into their own hands. I love the fact that Farmer really gives us the glimpses into the different experiences and influences that shape Matt. Throughout the book he recalls advice given to him by others, moments of love, moments of anger, moments of joy, everything that make him into the person at the end of the book who is willing to return to Opium in order to take control of the entire enterprise and bring it down—going with full acknowledgment that he might not make it. In the end I admired Matt for his fortitude and strength of character; he could have let the experiences in his life lead him to become another El Patron but he rose above them.
I enjoyed reading the book, and yet, I have to admit that despite Farmer’s ability to present serious and feasible issues in her text I will not actively pursue a greater diet of science fiction text than necessary—although I might have to check out the other books in this series just to see what happens. The book gave me horrible nightmares and while I know that some of that could have been heightened by the fever I had the day and night I read the book, I don’t enjoy thinking about these topics in such personal ways. Good literature affects me personally and Farmer’s text did just that; I admit my personal investment in Matt’s story despite its genre.
The most interesting piece of Farmer’s story was the stigma attached to being a clone. From the moment Matt’s foot is read by those in the Alacran house he is ostracized and viewed as nothing more than an animal. Rosa, the unfortunate housekeeper who is forced to care for Matt, literally treats him as an animal by providing him with newspapers as a lavatory. She eventually puts down chicken litter to make it easier for her to care for him. Willum, the doctor, remarks about Rosa’s decision saying, “You’re a strange woman, Rosa, but I have to admit the beast’s in good condition” (43). Even Maria, Matt’s only friend, continues to consider Matt to be an animal by comparing him to her dog, Furball. Eventually even Matt begins to believe that he is an animal. He tells Maria, “ ‘I am an animal,’ he replied. Once those words would have pained him, but he accepted his status now” (92). The only people who don’t treat him like an animal are Celia and Tam Lin. Both adults treat Matt like a human and expect more from him.
During El Patron’s 143rd birthday party, after Matt behaves like an animal in a figurative way. After the treatment of Tom, the embarrassing gift and kiss situation with Maria, the mysterious death of Furball, Matt’s anger turns to heartache as he realizes how his behavior can eventually poison his behavior and his future. Yet he remembers the words of Tam Lin, “Any rat in a sewer can lie….But a human doesn’t run and hide in dark places, because he’s something more” (134). At first this does nothing but drive Matt further into his own torment, but then he realizes that such a statement mirrors Tam Lin’s treatment of him as different from others. “He treated Matt as an equal” (138). In this Matt finds hope from, “Someone, out of all the people who thought he was no better than a dog, believed he could be something more” (139). It is from that moment on that Matt really decides to be a better person than Matteo Alacran, the original.
Matt and El Patron have a very strange relationship throughout the novel. I myself was very curious as to what the purpose for Matt’s creation and El Patron’s reason for not wanting to have a chip inserted into his brain. It was well into the novel that I began to doubt the sincerity and benevolence behind El Patron’s decisions. Every moment from then on in which there was any kind of foreshadow to perpetuate these thoughts, I physically cringed. It was heartbreaking for me and I tried to deny it as much as possible, just as Matt did, but when the awful truth came out I was terrified for Matt. It was only through my faith and trust in Celia, Tam Lin, and Maria to get him out safely that I was able to continue reading the book. When I get really involved in a novel it is hard for me to continue reading if I feel any apprehension for the well-being of the characters.
My favorite part in the book was when Tam Lin lets Matt know the secret about clones. He whispers into Matt’s ear, “No one can tell the difference between a clone and a human. That’s because there isn’t any difference. The idea of clones being inferior is a filthy lie” (245). This is something that helps Matt when he finally escapes Opium and enters Aztlan—escaping one dystopia for another. In Atzlan, Matt isn’t looked down upon for being a clone, instead he is singled out for being “the aristocrat” (280). With the Lost Boys and the Keepers Matt faces a new world filled with misplaced and hypocritical Socialists. The Keepers are unable to really practice what they preach and essentially imprison the boys while they spend the days eating and taking drugs. In this new land Matt gains his first male friends his own age who don’t treat him differently for being a clone—even after their initial misgivings. Matt is quick to point out to the Keepers that they are attempting to turn the boys into zombies or the eejits created in Opium.
I was relieved in the end when the all the boys finally see through their disillusionment and take things into their own hands. I love the fact that Farmer really gives us the glimpses into the different experiences and influences that shape Matt. Throughout the book he recalls advice given to him by others, moments of love, moments of anger, moments of joy, everything that make him into the person at the end of the book who is willing to return to Opium in order to take control of the entire enterprise and bring it down—going with full acknowledgment that he might not make it. In the end I admired Matt for his fortitude and strength of character; he could have let the experiences in his life lead him to become another El Patron but he rose above them.
I enjoyed reading the book, and yet, I have to admit that despite Farmer’s ability to present serious and feasible issues in her text I will not actively pursue a greater diet of science fiction text than necessary—although I might have to check out the other books in this series just to see what happens. The book gave me horrible nightmares and while I know that some of that could have been heightened by the fever I had the day and night I read the book, I don’t enjoy thinking about these topics in such personal ways. Good literature affects me personally and Farmer’s text did just that; I admit my personal investment in Matt’s story despite its genre.
Sunday, November 1, 2009
CI 5442: Fantasy Response #2
Being myself an avid fan of Greek and Roman mythology and having read both The Odyssey and The Aeneid—I even translated some of this from the Latin texts—I was intrigued to read Adèle Geras’ novel Troy. While the facts and figures from the text fit within my prior knowledge and understanding of the long siege of Troy, the book itself left me a little disappointed. While there were many elements I enjoyed in the story itself, I had a hard time connecting with the characters in a way that made me actually care for them on a personal level. Part of this might come from my aversion to stories with dramatic love triangles that seem trite, but I also think the number of characters contributed to my disinterest—not that I wanted anything bad to happen to them, but I was as involved in their lives as I wished to be. That being said, let’s talk about the things I did enjoy about the text.
The Gods. I thought the use of the gods and goddesses within the texts was brilliant! I loved the fact that they would come and disclose information about the present or future only to be dismissed as lunatics by the very people they conversed with in Troy. Characters within the text either found themselves completely disregarding the information provided by the gods and then simply forgetting what they heard or acknowledging their presence only to forget it anyway. The only character who was able to instantly recognize, believe, and remember the gods walking among them was Marpessa who’s near death experience seems to have given her some connection with the gods—at least that is my guess for her capabilities. It could also be her belief and continued exposure to them that allows her to recognize the gods when they appear to interfere with the citizens of Troy.
While some might think the constant interference of the gods and the inability of the citizens to remember them doesn’t fit within the text, I think it is the perfect way to not only explain some of the events that have, are, or will take place so that the audience can keep up with the intricacies of the Trojan War. The use of the gods also reinforces the idea that the gods were a constant part of the lives of the Trojans and Greeks alike. As Ares, the god of war, claims, “It’s not as easy as it looks, organizing things. Every battle has a plan, and every death, every wounding, has to be worked out. It’s exhausting, I can tell you. But it’s almost over…this war” (266). Ares goes further to explain that the gods are tired of the war and ready for it to be over, “It’s enough…That’s the feeling on Olympus. It’s all gone on long enough. I had to promise the end was in sight” (266). His presence throughout the text and the work of the other gods in orchestrating or divulging information about the war makes it explicitly clear who is in charge of Fate.
Geras also does an admirable job in showing the humanness of the gods. When the gods were created by the ancient peoples of the Mediterranean, they imagined them as possessing the same faults and humors as mankind as well as a similar appearance. The actions of the gods illustrate these human characteristics. Hermes loves to gossip and spread news, Hera feels the need to comfort, Artemis laments the loss of life, Hephaestus wants to make the best armor there is, Zeus seeks out human lovers, Ares plans battles, Poseidon has a temper that shakes the ground, both Hera and Athena are jealous and can hold a grudge, and Aphrodite needs lots and lots of attention and feels guilt over the amount of damage she unknowingly created. She says at the end of the book after Troy has been ravaged by war and fire, “‘As for that…’She looked toward Troy, now vanishing into the distance. ‘I didn’t really mean for so much destruction’” (356). They are human yet not and their actions influenced the course of history.
I also enjoyed the reflective nature of the situation in Troy and the characteristics of the gods with the characters in the book. The “Gossips” of the cooking women in the palace reminded me of the three “Fates” who decide, measure, and cut the life threads of all mortals. The women gossiping were forever discussing what was going on around them and the latest news that influenced the Fate of Troy. The jealousy of the goddesses was reflected in both the lives of the Trojan princes and princesses and the lives of their servants in Marpessa, Xanthe, and Iason with Alastor and Polyxena thrown into the mix. The wills of the gods also mirrored the wills and actions of the different armies and warriors as they battle tirelessly for ten years. The micro/macro parallel marks a good work of historical fiction—throw in the aid of the Greek gods, and Geras creates an exemplary piece of historical fantasy.
What I liked about Geras’ interpretation, besides the accuracy to ancient texts, is the fact that she was able to capture the anguish of the war and the destruction of lives on both sides of the wall—Greek and Trojan. While the Greeks may come out more as the villains, there is enough detail on both sides of the story to suggest that both sides were fighting an impossible war that had negative consequences and feelings all around; both nations have good and bad warriors and people living among them, both nations have people who regret the destruction caused by the war both in regards to human life and the city itself. I liked the inclusion of Greek thoughts at the end of the book that let the reader into the minds of different Greek warriors as they sacked, burned, and looted Troy. These thoughts gave us thoughts to balance those of the Trojans—some happily following orders to burn and loot, others questioning the decisions, orders, and actions of those in command; “Of course we couldn’t afford to leave Hector’s son alive. I see that. But there’s ways and ways. Kid wasn’t more than a baby. He could’ve been smothered with a pillow….But he wasn’t….That’s what I’ll see. That’s what I can’t stop seeing” (337-338). The narrator, whoever he is, cannot stomach or forget the image of Astyanax being tossed over the wall and onto the sharp rocks below showing a sense of humanity among the brute force of his commander.
Overall, Geras takes a very complex tale with a great amount of required background knowledge and reworks it into a text that is accessible and, perhaps, more appealing to younger readers. It reads very much like a modern Soap Opera-esque drama—like The Hills of an ancient era. I think the characters deal with timeless issues of love, hate, jealousy, and the overarching destruction of war; issues readers can still identify with. I think my own distaste for the overly dramatic realm of daytime television clouds my reading to some degree and denies my absolute love for the text, but there are many redeeming qualities that place it among novels that I like and admire. I wish that I could have learned more about the characters—their pasts and presents—in order to form a greater bond with them, but alas, it was not to be. When it comes down to it though, I think Geras does an admirable job and I can see myself recommending this book or maybe using it as a companion text to classical Greek and Roman literature.
The Gods. I thought the use of the gods and goddesses within the texts was brilliant! I loved the fact that they would come and disclose information about the present or future only to be dismissed as lunatics by the very people they conversed with in Troy. Characters within the text either found themselves completely disregarding the information provided by the gods and then simply forgetting what they heard or acknowledging their presence only to forget it anyway. The only character who was able to instantly recognize, believe, and remember the gods walking among them was Marpessa who’s near death experience seems to have given her some connection with the gods—at least that is my guess for her capabilities. It could also be her belief and continued exposure to them that allows her to recognize the gods when they appear to interfere with the citizens of Troy.
While some might think the constant interference of the gods and the inability of the citizens to remember them doesn’t fit within the text, I think it is the perfect way to not only explain some of the events that have, are, or will take place so that the audience can keep up with the intricacies of the Trojan War. The use of the gods also reinforces the idea that the gods were a constant part of the lives of the Trojans and Greeks alike. As Ares, the god of war, claims, “It’s not as easy as it looks, organizing things. Every battle has a plan, and every death, every wounding, has to be worked out. It’s exhausting, I can tell you. But it’s almost over…this war” (266). Ares goes further to explain that the gods are tired of the war and ready for it to be over, “It’s enough…That’s the feeling on Olympus. It’s all gone on long enough. I had to promise the end was in sight” (266). His presence throughout the text and the work of the other gods in orchestrating or divulging information about the war makes it explicitly clear who is in charge of Fate.
Geras also does an admirable job in showing the humanness of the gods. When the gods were created by the ancient peoples of the Mediterranean, they imagined them as possessing the same faults and humors as mankind as well as a similar appearance. The actions of the gods illustrate these human characteristics. Hermes loves to gossip and spread news, Hera feels the need to comfort, Artemis laments the loss of life, Hephaestus wants to make the best armor there is, Zeus seeks out human lovers, Ares plans battles, Poseidon has a temper that shakes the ground, both Hera and Athena are jealous and can hold a grudge, and Aphrodite needs lots and lots of attention and feels guilt over the amount of damage she unknowingly created. She says at the end of the book after Troy has been ravaged by war and fire, “‘As for that…’She looked toward Troy, now vanishing into the distance. ‘I didn’t really mean for so much destruction’” (356). They are human yet not and their actions influenced the course of history.
I also enjoyed the reflective nature of the situation in Troy and the characteristics of the gods with the characters in the book. The “Gossips” of the cooking women in the palace reminded me of the three “Fates” who decide, measure, and cut the life threads of all mortals. The women gossiping were forever discussing what was going on around them and the latest news that influenced the Fate of Troy. The jealousy of the goddesses was reflected in both the lives of the Trojan princes and princesses and the lives of their servants in Marpessa, Xanthe, and Iason with Alastor and Polyxena thrown into the mix. The wills of the gods also mirrored the wills and actions of the different armies and warriors as they battle tirelessly for ten years. The micro/macro parallel marks a good work of historical fiction—throw in the aid of the Greek gods, and Geras creates an exemplary piece of historical fantasy.
What I liked about Geras’ interpretation, besides the accuracy to ancient texts, is the fact that she was able to capture the anguish of the war and the destruction of lives on both sides of the wall—Greek and Trojan. While the Greeks may come out more as the villains, there is enough detail on both sides of the story to suggest that both sides were fighting an impossible war that had negative consequences and feelings all around; both nations have good and bad warriors and people living among them, both nations have people who regret the destruction caused by the war both in regards to human life and the city itself. I liked the inclusion of Greek thoughts at the end of the book that let the reader into the minds of different Greek warriors as they sacked, burned, and looted Troy. These thoughts gave us thoughts to balance those of the Trojans—some happily following orders to burn and loot, others questioning the decisions, orders, and actions of those in command; “Of course we couldn’t afford to leave Hector’s son alive. I see that. But there’s ways and ways. Kid wasn’t more than a baby. He could’ve been smothered with a pillow….But he wasn’t….That’s what I’ll see. That’s what I can’t stop seeing” (337-338). The narrator, whoever he is, cannot stomach or forget the image of Astyanax being tossed over the wall and onto the sharp rocks below showing a sense of humanity among the brute force of his commander.
Overall, Geras takes a very complex tale with a great amount of required background knowledge and reworks it into a text that is accessible and, perhaps, more appealing to younger readers. It reads very much like a modern Soap Opera-esque drama—like The Hills of an ancient era. I think the characters deal with timeless issues of love, hate, jealousy, and the overarching destruction of war; issues readers can still identify with. I think my own distaste for the overly dramatic realm of daytime television clouds my reading to some degree and denies my absolute love for the text, but there are many redeeming qualities that place it among novels that I like and admire. I wish that I could have learned more about the characters—their pasts and presents—in order to form a greater bond with them, but alas, it was not to be. When it comes down to it though, I think Geras does an admirable job and I can see myself recommending this book or maybe using it as a companion text to classical Greek and Roman literature.
Saturday, October 31, 2009
CI 5442: Fantasy Response #1
While it appears that some people don’t like David Almond’s novel Skellig, I thought it was a lovely story that left me wanting more. The text seemed a little slow at first, but once Mina and Michael are brought deeper and deeper into contact with Skellig and Michael’s sister’s life is placed in greater danger, I found myself enjoying the story and relationships between the characters. I enjoyed Almond’s use of William Blake’s poems and images to create a creature who teaches Michael and Mina the power of faith and love by giving them wings of their own.
What I thought was interesting in the text were the similarities between Skellig and Michael’s baby sister. Both are described as having pale white skin and black hair and they both are near death. It is only through care from Michael and Mina that Skellig becomes strong enough to recover on his own and it is only through the care of the doctors at the hospital and the positive thoughts of Michael and his family that the baby is able to survive her premature birth. It is as if the two of them are connected by their angel-like characteristics and their need for care in order to survive.
Perhaps my favorite part of the book was when Mina taught Michael to listen deeply to the night around them. From that moment on, Michael is able to deep listen for the thing that means the most to him; his baby sister—especially her heart. Michael says, “I listened through all these noises, until I heard the baby, the gentle squeaking of her breath, tiny and distant like it came from a different world….I listened deeper, until I believed I heard her beating heart” (96). From that moment on, he connects the beating of his own heart to that of his sister’s, “I touched my heart and I felt the baby’s heart beating beside my own” (97). This feeling carries on through the rest of the book and Michael fears the worse when he can no longer feel the her heart beating with his.
When it comes to love, Michael and Mina learn that they can help heal Skellig through their love of him—love that transfers into care. Likewise, the love and care received by Michael’s sister helps her grow strong and live. Michael asks a doctor at the hospital if love can heal people to which the doctor replies, “‘Love is the child that breathes our breath/Love is the child that scatters death,’” a quote from William Blake. The reference to Blake links back to the image of angels and, thus, Skellig. The line also suggests that love is a part of us—like our own child—and that the existence of love can overpower death.
Love is a powerful and—in this context—innocent creation that links the ability of Skellig to give the children wings and teach them to fly. In the book, there are several instances in which shoulder blades are connected with angels. Michael’s mother says, “They say shoulder blades are where your wings were, when you were an angel….They say they’re where your wings will grow again one day” (38-39). Angels are typically associated with innocence, children, and guardianship and the relationship between Michael, Mina, and Skellig reflects this. I believe these connections partially explain the ability of Skellig to give Michael, Mina, and Michael’s baby sister the brief ability to fly. The strong loving relationship between them allows Skellig to give the children a taste of the angelic life they might have once known and will someday know again.
When it comes to the baby girl in the story, I think it is powerful that Almond decided not to give her a name until the very end of the story. During the text Michael is told the myth of Persephone and how she comes back from the underworld every year. Michael thinks a lot about this myth and connects it to his sister. It’s is as if he wants her to be a strong as Persephone in fighting to make it in the world. He even suggests naming her Persephone but the family ultimately decides upon Joy, and that is what she is to the family.
Almond’s novel both excited me and confused me. I liked the premise of the story and the characters themselves, but I want to know more about Skellig; what is he, why is he there, why was he in such a state when Michael found him, etc. When I finished the book I felt not completely satisfied and with these questions still ringing in my mind. While I can try and make connections between the text and my prior knowledge of Blake and angels, I think it would take another reading to get try and make more deductions from the text and possibly satisfy my curiosity. Like I said, I wanted more!
I admit that Almond does a great job in weaving a story that is dynamic and engaging and I loved Skellig’s somewhat harsh personality and its dichotomy to the typical imaginative supposition of what an angel is. Almond leaves the reader guessing whether or not Skellig really is an angel or if he is an otherworldly creature with mystical healing powers—something I didn’t really like, but some might like the mystery surrounding such a strange character. I think students would really enjoy the reading this story and the intriguing characteristics of the people in Michael’s life from the enigmatic Mina, the crass Coot and Leakey, to Michael’s innocent baby sister, Joy.
What I thought was interesting in the text were the similarities between Skellig and Michael’s baby sister. Both are described as having pale white skin and black hair and they both are near death. It is only through care from Michael and Mina that Skellig becomes strong enough to recover on his own and it is only through the care of the doctors at the hospital and the positive thoughts of Michael and his family that the baby is able to survive her premature birth. It is as if the two of them are connected by their angel-like characteristics and their need for care in order to survive.
Perhaps my favorite part of the book was when Mina taught Michael to listen deeply to the night around them. From that moment on, Michael is able to deep listen for the thing that means the most to him; his baby sister—especially her heart. Michael says, “I listened through all these noises, until I heard the baby, the gentle squeaking of her breath, tiny and distant like it came from a different world….I listened deeper, until I believed I heard her beating heart” (96). From that moment on, he connects the beating of his own heart to that of his sister’s, “I touched my heart and I felt the baby’s heart beating beside my own” (97). This feeling carries on through the rest of the book and Michael fears the worse when he can no longer feel the her heart beating with his.
When it comes to love, Michael and Mina learn that they can help heal Skellig through their love of him—love that transfers into care. Likewise, the love and care received by Michael’s sister helps her grow strong and live. Michael asks a doctor at the hospital if love can heal people to which the doctor replies, “‘Love is the child that breathes our breath/Love is the child that scatters death,’” a quote from William Blake. The reference to Blake links back to the image of angels and, thus, Skellig. The line also suggests that love is a part of us—like our own child—and that the existence of love can overpower death.
Love is a powerful and—in this context—innocent creation that links the ability of Skellig to give the children wings and teach them to fly. In the book, there are several instances in which shoulder blades are connected with angels. Michael’s mother says, “They say shoulder blades are where your wings were, when you were an angel….They say they’re where your wings will grow again one day” (38-39). Angels are typically associated with innocence, children, and guardianship and the relationship between Michael, Mina, and Skellig reflects this. I believe these connections partially explain the ability of Skellig to give Michael, Mina, and Michael’s baby sister the brief ability to fly. The strong loving relationship between them allows Skellig to give the children a taste of the angelic life they might have once known and will someday know again.
When it comes to the baby girl in the story, I think it is powerful that Almond decided not to give her a name until the very end of the story. During the text Michael is told the myth of Persephone and how she comes back from the underworld every year. Michael thinks a lot about this myth and connects it to his sister. It’s is as if he wants her to be a strong as Persephone in fighting to make it in the world. He even suggests naming her Persephone but the family ultimately decides upon Joy, and that is what she is to the family.
Almond’s novel both excited me and confused me. I liked the premise of the story and the characters themselves, but I want to know more about Skellig; what is he, why is he there, why was he in such a state when Michael found him, etc. When I finished the book I felt not completely satisfied and with these questions still ringing in my mind. While I can try and make connections between the text and my prior knowledge of Blake and angels, I think it would take another reading to get try and make more deductions from the text and possibly satisfy my curiosity. Like I said, I wanted more!
I admit that Almond does a great job in weaving a story that is dynamic and engaging and I loved Skellig’s somewhat harsh personality and its dichotomy to the typical imaginative supposition of what an angel is. Almond leaves the reader guessing whether or not Skellig really is an angel or if he is an otherworldly creature with mystical healing powers—something I didn’t really like, but some might like the mystery surrounding such a strange character. I think students would really enjoy the reading this story and the intriguing characteristics of the people in Michael’s life from the enigmatic Mina, the crass Coot and Leakey, to Michael’s innocent baby sister, Joy.
Sunday, October 25, 2009
CI 5442: Historical Fiction Reponse
The novel Kira-Kira by Cynthia Kadohata turned out to be exactly as the segments of reviews printed on the back cover stated it to be; it shines and speaks to readers as Kadohata tells Katie Takeshima’s bittersweet story of family, love, and loss. Kadohata is able to see the world through the eyes of a young child in the 1950’s who is forced to make many difficult adjustments in the young life. The deep family relationships bring the characters into perspective; Kadohata details the account of a dynamic family struggling to make a brighter future.
I absolutely love the title of the book, Kira-Kira; before I even knew what it meant, the lyrical quality drew me in. Within the first few pages readers are told that kira-kira is Japanese for “glittering,” such a simple yet prolific word. Lynn tells Katie that the sky is kira-kira because “‘the color is deep but see-through both at the same time’” just like the ocean and people’s eyes (3). As a curious reader, I wanted to know why this word was so important—why was it chosen as the title for this book? It wasn’t until much later in the text that I determined why I thought Kadohata chose this word for the title; to me it represented to relationship between Katie and Lynn as well as Lynn’s “theme.”
The relationship between Katie and Lynn is fascinating. The two are inseparable and Lynn always ensures that her sister is cared for, a duty that Lynn takes very seriously. Lynn is the one that looks out for Katie and has “serious talks” with her; Lynn tells Katie that they are moving to Georgia, that Katie might not make friends at school because of prejudices against them, and she tells Katie when their mother is pregnant. While Lynn takes care of Katie, Katie idolizes Lynn. She looks up to her as a genius and friend. They spend a lot of time looking at the sky, making wishes and promises about their future lives, and worrying about their parents. Katie agrees with everything that Lynn tells her and finally Lynn asks, “‘Do you agree with me all the time just because I say so or because you really, truly agree with me?’ I didn’t see the difference between the two things, so I just said I didn’t know” (60). Katie’s reply illustrates her undeniable love and admiration for her big sister.
Things changes when Lynn becomes friends with a girl from school and her behavior changes from being that of a friend to being that of an older sister, alone. The realistic shift from childish antics to boy-crazy attitudes that adolescents experience is chronicled through Katie’s eyes and is, thus, illustrated as a waste of time. Kadohata brilliantly explores this shift through Katie’s young eyes, expressing her confusion with Lynn’s behavior. She stops agreeing with Lynn and begins to feel like a child in her presence. Katie notices one day, “Whenever I try to talk to her, she made me feel immature, even if she didn’t mean to” (120).
While the relationship between Katie and Lynn changes, so does the relationship of the entire family. A major theme of the book—and the Takeshima family—is duty. Katie’s parents know it is their duty to do what is best for their family and provide them with the things they need; this duty drives the family from Iowa to Georgia, it pushes Katie’s parents to work hours and hours each week I order to save enough money to buy a house, it causes them to take out a loan from the bank in order to get that house—something they would never have done if not for Lynn’s condition. Lynn feels it is her duty to take care of Katie, and Katie feels it is her duty to take care of Sammy. When Lynn becomes sick, Katie believes it is her duty to take care of her. Even after Lynn’s death, both Katie and her parents try to protect and take care of each other the best they can. The relationship of the entire family is strained by Lynn’s sickness and threatens to disintegrate, but after Lynn’s death they go on. Katie remarks on how her father only took two days to grieve for Lynn before getting back into his normal routine, “He needed to think about his children who were still alive, because he was honor-bound to think of the living before the dead” (240). Through Lynn’s death the family is brought back together and each of them take something away from the experience.
I thought the setting of the story affected the characters as they struggle to overcome adversity. What is interesting about the book is that the characters are so realistic, that I would often forget the story was set in the 1950s until the girls would mention something relating to the prejudice they faced or specific time-telling things like how much money a dollar seemed to be. I would become so absorbed in the lives of the characters as simply people, that the time period would float in and out of my consciousness. I am not trying to diminish the significance of the historical setting, but there are so many other aspects of the novel that intrigued me as well. Kadohata does create a setting that is realistic and imaginable—you can live it with Katie.
Kadohata’s book is about hope and the ability to achieve a brighter future. Lynn lived for the future and forced those around her to do the same; she loved to look at the sky, the infinite beyond that was full of the same possibilities as their futures. She was always talking about the great things she would accomplish in her life, the great things that Katie would accomplish in hers. It is by preserving this hope and remembering the infinite possibilities of the future that she was able to look at the world in a different way from those around her. Katie writes in her essay for school, “Lynn could take a simple everyday object, like a box of Kleenex and use it to prove how amazing the world is….This is the main theme of my sister’s life” (224). Lynn believed that everything in life could be described as kira-kira if you look at it the right way. Lynn’s death was a heart-wrenching event for her entire family, and yet they each grew from it in a positive way; they took something and made it beautiful, made it kira-kira.
I absolutely love the title of the book, Kira-Kira; before I even knew what it meant, the lyrical quality drew me in. Within the first few pages readers are told that kira-kira is Japanese for “glittering,” such a simple yet prolific word. Lynn tells Katie that the sky is kira-kira because “‘the color is deep but see-through both at the same time’” just like the ocean and people’s eyes (3). As a curious reader, I wanted to know why this word was so important—why was it chosen as the title for this book? It wasn’t until much later in the text that I determined why I thought Kadohata chose this word for the title; to me it represented to relationship between Katie and Lynn as well as Lynn’s “theme.”
The relationship between Katie and Lynn is fascinating. The two are inseparable and Lynn always ensures that her sister is cared for, a duty that Lynn takes very seriously. Lynn is the one that looks out for Katie and has “serious talks” with her; Lynn tells Katie that they are moving to Georgia, that Katie might not make friends at school because of prejudices against them, and she tells Katie when their mother is pregnant. While Lynn takes care of Katie, Katie idolizes Lynn. She looks up to her as a genius and friend. They spend a lot of time looking at the sky, making wishes and promises about their future lives, and worrying about their parents. Katie agrees with everything that Lynn tells her and finally Lynn asks, “‘Do you agree with me all the time just because I say so or because you really, truly agree with me?’ I didn’t see the difference between the two things, so I just said I didn’t know” (60). Katie’s reply illustrates her undeniable love and admiration for her big sister.
Things changes when Lynn becomes friends with a girl from school and her behavior changes from being that of a friend to being that of an older sister, alone. The realistic shift from childish antics to boy-crazy attitudes that adolescents experience is chronicled through Katie’s eyes and is, thus, illustrated as a waste of time. Kadohata brilliantly explores this shift through Katie’s young eyes, expressing her confusion with Lynn’s behavior. She stops agreeing with Lynn and begins to feel like a child in her presence. Katie notices one day, “Whenever I try to talk to her, she made me feel immature, even if she didn’t mean to” (120).
While the relationship between Katie and Lynn changes, so does the relationship of the entire family. A major theme of the book—and the Takeshima family—is duty. Katie’s parents know it is their duty to do what is best for their family and provide them with the things they need; this duty drives the family from Iowa to Georgia, it pushes Katie’s parents to work hours and hours each week I order to save enough money to buy a house, it causes them to take out a loan from the bank in order to get that house—something they would never have done if not for Lynn’s condition. Lynn feels it is her duty to take care of Katie, and Katie feels it is her duty to take care of Sammy. When Lynn becomes sick, Katie believes it is her duty to take care of her. Even after Lynn’s death, both Katie and her parents try to protect and take care of each other the best they can. The relationship of the entire family is strained by Lynn’s sickness and threatens to disintegrate, but after Lynn’s death they go on. Katie remarks on how her father only took two days to grieve for Lynn before getting back into his normal routine, “He needed to think about his children who were still alive, because he was honor-bound to think of the living before the dead” (240). Through Lynn’s death the family is brought back together and each of them take something away from the experience.
I thought the setting of the story affected the characters as they struggle to overcome adversity. What is interesting about the book is that the characters are so realistic, that I would often forget the story was set in the 1950s until the girls would mention something relating to the prejudice they faced or specific time-telling things like how much money a dollar seemed to be. I would become so absorbed in the lives of the characters as simply people, that the time period would float in and out of my consciousness. I am not trying to diminish the significance of the historical setting, but there are so many other aspects of the novel that intrigued me as well. Kadohata does create a setting that is realistic and imaginable—you can live it with Katie.
Kadohata’s book is about hope and the ability to achieve a brighter future. Lynn lived for the future and forced those around her to do the same; she loved to look at the sky, the infinite beyond that was full of the same possibilities as their futures. She was always talking about the great things she would accomplish in her life, the great things that Katie would accomplish in hers. It is by preserving this hope and remembering the infinite possibilities of the future that she was able to look at the world in a different way from those around her. Katie writes in her essay for school, “Lynn could take a simple everyday object, like a box of Kleenex and use it to prove how amazing the world is….This is the main theme of my sister’s life” (224). Lynn believed that everything in life could be described as kira-kira if you look at it the right way. Lynn’s death was a heart-wrenching event for her entire family, and yet they each grew from it in a positive way; they took something and made it beautiful, made it kira-kira.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)